63 Wins, 59 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/01/86 | Won | Bethel 51 | Jefferson 45 | League | 6.921 |
| 02/04/87 | Won | Bethel 52 | Lakes 46 | League | 6.680 |
| 12/10/87 | Won | Bethel 50 | North Thurston 43 | Non-league | 6.237 |
| 12/14/87 | Lost | Bethel 33 | Clover Park 39 | League | 11.870 |
| 01/13/88 | Won | Bethel 45 | Sumner 43 | League | 2.662 |
| 12/15/88 | Won | Bethel 50 | Lakes 40 | League | 4.024 |
| 01/04/89 | Won | Bethel 48 | Curtis 44 | League | 0.672 |
| 01/07/89 | Won | Bethel 50 | Spanaway Lake 43 | League | 1.976 |
| 11/30/89 | Won | Bethel 56 | Yelm 42 | Non-league | 2.000 |
| 01/11/90 | Lost | Bethel 38 | Kentwood 46 | League | 2.651 |
| 02/21/90 | Won | Bethel 45 | Foss 39 | Playoff | 3.131 |
| 02/28/90 | Lost | Bethel 35 | Port Angeles 38 | Playoff | 3.223 |
| 11/29/90 | Won | Bethel 41 | Lakes 38 | Non-league | 7.520 |
| 01/08/91 | Won | Bethel 53 | Rogers (Puyallup) 36 | League | 4.857 |
| 01/12/91 | Lost | Bethel 36 | Yelm 49 | Non-league | 4.944 |
| 02/05/91 | Won | Bethel 49 | Rogers (Puyallup) 32 | League | 4.857 |
| 02/08/91 | Lost | Bethel 55 | Kentwood 59 | League | 17.567 |
| 02/16/91 | Won | Bethel 63 | Kent-Meridian 45 | Playoff | 0.036 |
| 02/22/91 | Won | Bethel 39 | Wilson 38 | Playoff | 7.167 |
| 12/10/91 | Won | Bethel 49 | Decatur 44 | Non-league | 1.096 |
| 12/20/91 | Lost | Bethel 46 | Sumner 55 | League | 7.052 |
| 01/07/92 | Won | Bethel 50 | Lakes 49 | League | 18.162 |
| 01/14/92 | Lost | Bethel 41 | Curtis 51 | League | 1.502 |
| 12/05/92 | Lost | Bethel 35 | South Kitsap 40 | Non-league | 2.057 |
| 12/17/92 | Won | Bethel 57 | Sumner 52 | League | 6.943 |
| 01/12/93 | Won | Bethel 42 | Rogers (Puyallup) 32 | League | 9.534 |
| 01/26/93 | Won | Bethel 63 | Sumner 55 | League | 6.943 |
| 12/21/93 | Lost | Bethel 48 | Central Kitsap 57 | Non-league | 3.529 |
| 01/04/94 | Won | Bethel 56 | Curtis 45 | League | 2.994 |
| 01/25/94 | Won | Bethel 62 | Lakes 36 | League | 3.220 |
| 01/13/95 | Lost | Bethel 67 | Spanaway Lake 69 | League | 11.522 |
| 01/26/95 | Won | Bethel 56 | Curtis 45 | League | 0.126 |
| 02/10/95 | Lost | Bethel 51 | Spanaway Lake 52 | League | 11.522 |
| 02/18/95 | Lost | Bethel 41 | Kentridge 59 | Playoff | 7.047 |
| 01/03/96 | Lost | Bethel 49 | Curtis 62 | League | 5.279 |
| 02/06/96 | Won | Bethel 49 | Sumner 47 | League | 5.137 |
| 01/07/97 | Won | Bethel 41 | Rogers (Puyallup) 30 | League | 0.155 |
| 12/16/97 | Lost | Bethel 45 | Decatur 57 | League | 8.213 |
| 12/30/97 | Won | Bethel 57 | Tahoma 55 | Non-league | 14.076 |
| 01/09/98 | Won | Bethel 59 | Jefferson 46 | League | 0.352 |
| 12/08/98 | Lost | Bethel 54 | Federal Way 59 | League | 6.701 |
| 12/19/98 | Lost | Bethel 42 | Sumner 43 | League | 11.568 |
| 01/22/99 | Lost | Bethel 42 | Federal Way 46 | League | 6.701 |
| 03/02/00 | Lost | Bethel 51 | Bellarmine Prep 65 | Playoff | 4.354 |
| 03/09/00 | Lost | Bethel 48 | Decatur 51 | Playoff | 9.258 |
| 01/18/01 | Lost | Bethel 43 | Rogers (Puyallup) 47 | League | 4.936 |
| 01/26/01 | Lost | Bethel 53 | Jefferson 60 | League | 6.843 |
| 02/17/01 | Won | Bethel 54 | Enumclaw 50 | Playoff | 2.337 |
| 03/03/01 | Won | Bethel 49 | Enumclaw 45 | Playoff | 2.337 |
| 11/30/01 | Lost | Bethel 43 | Issaquah 45 | Non-league | 0.214 |
| 12/11/01 | Lost | Bethel 35 | Rogers (Puyallup) 43 | League | 0.800 |
| 12/18/01 | Won | Bethel 59 | Jefferson 58 | League | 7.098 |
| 01/04/02 | Lost | Bethel 53 | Curtis 54 | League | 10.505 |
| 01/08/02 | Lost | Bethel 56 | Decatur 59 | League | 3.638 |
| 01/26/02 | Lost | Bethel 41 | Puyallup 43 | League | 6.058 |
| 12/17/02 | Lost | Bethel 44 | Rogers (Puyallup) 45 | League | 0.551 |
| 01/21/03 | Won | Bethel 53 | Decatur 46 | League | 2.886 |
| 02/04/03 | Won | Bethel 43 | Decatur 37 | League | 2.886 |
| 01/23/04 | Won | Bethel 51 | Curtis 40 | League | 5.414 |
| 01/29/04 | Lost | Bethel 51 | Decatur 58 | League | 5.053 |
| 02/03/04 | Lost | Bethel 37 | Decatur 49 | League | 5.053 |
| 02/21/04 | Lost | Bethel 50 | Kentwood 55 | Playoff | 2.308 |
| 03/11/04 | Lost | Bethel 28 | Gig Harbor 38 | Playoff | 4.558 |
| 03/10/05 | Lost | Bethel 32 | Gig Harbor 36 | Playoff | 7.761 |
| 11/29/05 | Lost | Bethel 47 | Federal Way 58 | League | 2.304 |
| 01/03/06 | Won | Bethel 59 | Puyallup 55 | League | 7.787 |
| 01/12/06 | Lost | Bethel 58 | Federal Way 66 | League | 2.304 |
| 01/14/06 | Lost | Bethel 46 | Graham-Kapowsin 55 | League | 7.675 |
| 02/02/06 | Lost | Bethel 57 | Curtis 61 | League | 14.421 |
| 12/09/06 | Won | Bethel 55 | Bellarmine Prep 42 | Non-league | 3.618 |
| 12/19/06 | Won | Bethel 46 | Graham-Kapowsin 34 | League | 2.812 |
| 01/27/07 | Lost | Bethel 40 | Rogers (Puyallup) 54 | League | 5.081 |
| 01/30/07 | Lost | Bethel 44 | Puyallup 51 | League | 0.819 |
| 02/01/07 | Won | Bethel 51 | Graham-Kapowsin 46 | League | 2.812 |
| 02/14/07 | Lost | Bethel 56 | Central Kitsap 58 | Playoff | 3.890 |
| 11/30/07 | Won | Bethel 60 | Enumclaw 51 | Non-league | 1.044 |
| 12/27/07 | Won | Bethel 57 | Cascade (Everett) 56 | Non-league | 0.326 |
| 12/29/07 | Won | Bethel 47 | White River 46 | Non-league | 0.598 |
| 01/29/08 | Won | Bethel 49 | Puyallup 41 | League | 1.210 |
| 02/01/08 | Won | Bethel 48 | Graham-Kapowsin 46 | League | 2.752 |
| 02/14/08 | Lost | Bethel 41 | Jefferson 50 | Playoff | 1.576 |
| 02/16/08 | Lost | Bethel 52 | Kentlake 56 | Playoff | 3.927 |
| 12/13/08 | Lost | Bethel 44 | Curtis 55 | League | 10.299 |
| 01/14/09 | Won | Bethel 51 | Emerald Ridge 45 | League | 1.797 |
| 02/20/09 | Won | Bethel 59 | Gig Harbor 56 | Playoff | 4.509 |
| 12/02/09 | Lost | Bethel 35 | Central Kitsap 51 | Non-league | 3.010 |
| 12/10/09 | Won | Bethel 45 | Rogers (Puyallup) 43 | League | 4.629 |
| 12/22/09 | Won | Bethel 53 | Kentlake 40 | Non-league | 4.377 |
| 01/12/10 | Won | Bethel 42 | Puyallup 39 | League | 3.378 |
| 02/02/10 | Won | Bethel 42 | Puyallup 34 | League | 3.378 |
| 02/20/10 | Won | Bethel 52 | Auburn 43 | Playoff | 4.425 |
| 02/24/10 | Won | Bethel 55 | South Kitsap 44 | Playoff | 8.326 |
| 11/30/10 | Won | Bethel 35 | Yelm 30 | Non-league | 3.897 |
| 12/28/10 | Lost | Bethel 45 | Bonney Lake 47 | Non-league | 1.729 |
| 12/29/10 | Won | Bethel 48 | Snohomish 40 | Non-league | 7.468 |
| 01/21/11 | Lost | Bethel 54 | Beamer 63 | League | 0.398 |
| 02/04/11 | Lost | Bethel 30 | Spanaway Lake 42 | League | 0.987 |
| 02/12/11 | Lost | Bethel 42 | Auburn 53 | Playoff | 2.508 |
| 01/03/12 | Won | Bethel 48 | Emerald Ridge 43 | League | 5.089 |
| 01/26/12 | Lost | Bethel 50 | Puyallup 53 | League | 7.510 |
| 02/15/12 | Won | Bethel 44 | Emerald Ridge 42 | Playoff | 5.089 |
| 02/17/12 | Lost | Bethel 39 | Rogers (Puyallup) 54 | Playoff | 0.115 |
| 02/18/12 | Won | Bethel 54 | Battle Ground 28 | Playoff | 0.257 |
| 12/13/12 | Won | Bethel 45 | Federal Way 32 | League | 4.745 |
| 01/03/13 | Lost | Bethel 36 | Emerald Ridge 41 | League | 7.076 |
| 02/09/13 | Lost | Bethel 49 | Tahoma 52 | Playoff | 1.678 |
| 12/05/13 | Won | Bethel 49 | Curtis 44 | League | 4.345 |
| 12/30/13 | Won | Bethel 57 | Yelm 39 | Non-league | 3.222 |
| 01/24/14 | Lost | Bethel 41 | Federal Way 44 | League | 6.415 |
| 12/02/14 | Won | Bethel 45 | Union 37 | Non-league | 0.001 |
| 01/06/15 | Won | Bethel 42 | Curtis 33 | League | 10.295 |
| 12/11/15 | Won | Bethel 53 | Rogers (Puyallup) 50 | League | 9.521 |
| 01/19/16 | Won | Bethel 50 | Puyallup 40 | League | 5.524 |
| 02/06/16 | Lost | Bethel 39 | Emerald Ridge 45 | Playoff | 7.455 |
| 03/01/18 | Lost | Bethel 52 | Gig Harbor 57 | Playoff | 4.303 |
| 03/02/18 | Lost | Bethel 45 | Seattle Prep 60 | Playoff | 5.600 |
| 12/01/18 | Lost | Bethel 48 | Roosevelt 63 | Non-league | 1.398 |
| 12/26/18 | Lost | Bethel 41 | Franklin 48 | Non-league | 7.315 |
| 12/28/18 | Lost | Bethel 50 | Annie Wright 64 | Non-league | 4.827 |
| 02/15/19 | Won | Bethel 54 | Prairie 37 | Playoff | 23.490 |
| 02/16/19 | Won | Bethel 58 | Peninsula 47 | Playoff | 2.683 |
| 02/19/20 | Lost | Bethel 52 | Lincoln (Tacoma) 55 | Playoff | 11.837 |
39 Wins, 24 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/13/02 | Lost | Bethel 44 | Federal Way 46 | League | 6.848 |
| 02/01/03 | Lost | Bethel 42 | Puyallup 52 | League | 6.976 |
| 03/01/03 | Lost | Bethel 64 | Prairie 67 | Playoff | 3.664 |
| 03/14/03 | Lost | Bethel 36 | South Kitsap 46 | Playoff | 1.321 |
| 02/27/04 | Lost | Bethel 43 | South Kitsap 51 | Playoff | 1.625 |
| 03/12/04 | Lost | Bethel 47 | South Kitsap 49 | Playoff | 1.625 |
| 12/10/04 | Lost | Bethel 70 | Curtis 72 | League | 5.002 |
| 01/25/05 | Lost | Bethel 55 | Federal Way 56 | League | 4.151 |
| 02/19/05 | Won | Bethel 59 | Kentwood 52 | Playoff | 0.845 |
| 03/05/05 | Won | Bethel 54 | South Kitsap 53 | Playoff | 2.190 |
| 03/11/05 | Won | Bethel 47 | Mountlake Terrace 44 | Playoff | 1.861 |
| 03/12/05 | Won | Bethel 33 | Kentwood 29 | Playoff | 0.845 |
| 12/09/05 | Won | Bethel 72 | Rogers (Puyallup) 64 | League | 0.491 |
| 12/13/05 | Won | Bethel 61 | Decatur 60 | League | 12.020 |
| 01/31/06 | Lost | Bethel 46 | Beamer 53 | League | 4.191 |
| 02/16/06 | Won | Bethel 62 | Auburn 58 | Playoff | 3.174 |
| 12/02/06 | Won | Bethel 46 | Lincoln 41 | Non-league | 5.060 |
| 12/29/06 | Won | Bethel 43 | Roosevelt 42 | Non-league | 5.150 |
| 01/09/07 | Lost | Bethel 35 | Puyallup 42 | League | 7.308 |
| 02/15/07 | Won | Bethel 54 | Lincoln 47 | Playoff | 5.060 |
| 02/17/07 | Won | Bethel 58 | Kentwood 44 | Playoff | 6.417 |
| 02/21/07 | Won | Bethel 59 | Curtis 49 | Playoff | 4.457 |
| 11/27/07 | Lost | Bethel 61 | Mount Tahoma 69 | Non-league | 4.920 |
| 12/11/07 | Won | Bethel 62 | Curtis 53 | League | 4.688 |
| 01/29/08 | Lost | Bethel 70 | Puyallup 78 | League | 3.855 |
| 02/09/08 | Won | Bethel 65 | Decatur 64 | Playoff | 15.517 |
| 02/13/08 | Won | Bethel 62 | Central Kitsap 56 | Playoff | 2.580 |
| 01/31/09 | Lost | Bethel 62 | Emerald Ridge 66 | League | 5.077 |
| 02/03/09 | Won | Bethel 62 | Puyallup 59 | League | 7.799 |
| 01/19/10 | Won | Bethel 57 | Rogers (Puyallup) 51 | League | 1.253 |
| 02/09/10 | Won | Bethel 73 | Rogers (Puyallup) 59 | Playoff | 1.253 |
| 12/21/10 | Won | Bethel 70 | Foss 60 | Non-league | 6.714 |
| 01/05/11 | Won | Bethel 60 | Federal Way 54 | League | 8.461 |
| 01/21/11 | Lost | Bethel 46 | Beamer 64 | League | 6.340 |
| 02/12/11 | Won | Bethel 60 | Kentlake 49 | Playoff | 8.128 |
| 01/03/12 | Won | Bethel 54 | Emerald Ridge 45 | League | 7.650 |
| 12/15/12 | Won | Bethel 78 | Beamer 71 | League | 3.908 |
| 01/03/13 | Lost | Bethel 47 | Emerald Ridge 48 | League | 3.209 |
| 02/01/13 | Lost | Bethel 58 | Spanaway Lake 59 | League | 4.554 |
| 02/09/13 | Lost | Bethel 51 | Jefferson 53 | Playoff | 7.564 |
| 02/18/13 | Won | Bethel 70 | Beamer 64 | Playoff | 3.908 |
| 12/30/13 | Lost | Bethel 48 | Mount Tahoma 50 | Non-league | 7.623 |
| 01/03/14 | Won | Bethel 48 | Rogers (Puyallup) 46 | League | 0.761 |
| 01/31/14 | Won | Bethel 55 | Rogers (Puyallup) 50 | League | 0.761 |
| 02/04/14 | Won | Bethel 46 | Emerald Ridge 42 | League | 1.412 |
| 12/09/14 | Won | Bethel 68 | Emerald Ridge 67 | League | 0.954 |
| 12/13/14 | Won | Bethel 68 | South Kitsap 60 | Non-league | 6.662 |
| 12/16/14 | Won | Bethel 48 | Spanaway Lake 46 | League | 4.299 |
| 12/20/14 | Lost | Bethel 56 | Juanita 57 | Non-league | 8.737 |
| 12/23/14 | Lost | Bethel 49 | Decatur 54 | Non-league | 2.607 |
| 01/05/15 | Won | Bethel 63 | Rogers (Puyallup) 57 | League | 5.872 |
| 01/12/15 | Lost | Bethel 52 | Graham-Kapowsin 60 | League | 6.496 |
| 01/20/15 | Won | Bethel 53 | Spanaway Lake 49 | League | 4.299 |
| 12/11/15 | Won | Bethel 50 | Rogers (Puyallup) 44 | League | 2.456 |
| 12/19/15 | Won | Bethel 57 | Mount Rainier 53 | Non-league | 0.565 |
| 01/29/16 | Lost | Bethel 55 | Graham-Kapowsin 57 | League | 13.970 |
| 12/29/16 | Won | Bethel 51 | Kentlake 49 | Non-league | 9.865 |
| 01/23/17 | Won | Bethel 65 | Mount Tahoma 60 | League | 11.335 |
| 12/29/17 | Lost | Bethel 53 | Graham-Kapowsin 59 | Non-league | 2.620 |
| 01/06/18 | Won | Bethel 62 | Jefferson 61 | Non-league | 1.530 |
| 01/17/18 | Won | Bethel 59 | Lakes 46 | League | 10.390 |
| 12/28/19 | Lost | Bethel 66 | River Ridge 68 | Non-league | 4.128 |
| 01/15/20 | Won | Bethel 76 | Mount Tahoma 71 | League | 19.599 |