8 Wins, 17 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/19/87 | Lost | Crescent 40 | Bremerton Christian 47 | Non-league | 3.426 |
| 01/30/88 | Lost | Crescent 46 | Evergreen Lutheran 70 | Non-league | 0.115 |
| 02/05/88 | Won | Crescent 51 | Clallam Bay 49 | League | 6.081 |
| 01/18/91 | Won | Crescent 45 | Clallam Bay 44 | League | 15.299 |
| 01/04/94 | Lost | Crescent 32 | University Prep 39 | Non-league | 0.340 |
| 12/10/94 | Won | Crescent 46 | Christian Faith 36 | Non-league | 3.882 |
| 01/07/95 | Lost | Crescent 27 | Bush 29 | Non-league | 18.925 |
| 02/18/95 | Won | Crescent 50 | Christian Faith 48 | Playoff | 3.882 |
| 01/19/96 | Lost | Crescent 42 | Neah Bay 45 | League | 2.197 |
| 02/09/99 | Lost | Crescent 43 | Quilcene 47 | League | 4.264 |
| 12/05/02 | Lost | Crescent 45 | Chimacum 50 | Non-league | 9.228 |
| 12/20/02 | Lost | Crescent 36 | Rainier Christian 41 | Non-league | 0.560 |
| 12/27/02 | Lost | Crescent 46 | Forest Ridge 58 | Non-league | 0.680 |
| 12/28/02 | Lost | Crescent 36 | Concrete 47 | Non-league | 7.400 |
| 12/05/03 | Lost | Crescent 53 | Chimacum 56 | Non-league | 5.911 |
| 01/23/04 | Lost | Crescent 51 | Quilcene 52 | League | 7.705 |
| 02/03/04 | Lost | Crescent 66 | Quilcene 67 | League | 7.705 |
| 12/28/04 | Lost | Crescent 31 | Vancouver Christian 40 | Non-league | 0.084 |
| 01/12/07 | Lost | Crescent 26 | Clallam Bay 33 | League | 2.353 |
| 12/29/08 | Won | Crescent 44 | Quilcene 32 | Non-league | 2.997 |
| 01/05/11 | Won | Crescent 46 | Chimacum 17 | Non-league | 17.975 |
| 12/14/11 | Lost | Crescent 22 | Clallam Bay 26 | Non-league | 7.706 |
| 12/04/12 | Won | Crescent 27 | Quilcene 24 | Non-league | 6.775 |
| 01/16/13 | Lost | Crescent 22 | Clallam Bay 25 | League | 2.383 |
| 12/06/14 | Won | Crescent 46 | Oakville 33 | Non-league | 10.769 |
18 Wins, 15 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/12/03 | Won | Crescent 56 | Chimacum 52 | Non-league | 17.648 |
| 12/29/03 | Lost | Crescent 59 | Lake Quinault 70 | Non-league | 2.146 |
| 12/05/05 | Won | Crescent 51 | Port Angeles 37 | Non-league | 32.023 |
| 12/16/05 | Lost | Crescent 43 | Christian Faith 44 | Non-league | 8.265 |
| 12/30/05 | Lost | Crescent 45 | Bear Creek 59 | Non-league | 0.188 |
| 01/02/06 | Won | Crescent 47 | Port Angeles 46 | Non-league | 32.023 |
| 01/04/06 | Won | Crescent 48 | Quilcene 47 | League | 2.767 |
| 01/06/06 | Lost | Crescent 34 | Clallam Bay 41 | League | 16.279 |
| 01/20/06 | Lost | Crescent 41 | Clallam Bay 43 | League | 16.279 |
| 12/16/06 | Lost | Crescent 40 | Mary M. Knight 51 | Non-league | 3.651 |
| 12/29/06 | Won | Crescent 65 | Christian Faith 61 | Non-league | 2.422 |
| 01/19/07 | Won | Crescent 58 | Neah Bay 43 | League | 2.265 |
| 01/24/07 | Lost | Crescent 35 | Clallam Bay 41 | League | 4.526 |
| 02/02/07 | Lost | Crescent 42 | Clallam Bay 47 | League | 4.526 |
| 12/30/10 | Won | Crescent 41 | Quilcene 40 | Non-league | 5.406 |
| 12/06/11 | Lost | Crescent 58 | Quilcene 62 | Non-league | 12.101 |
| 12/10/11 | Lost | Crescent 44 | Taholah 52 | Non-league | 0.921 |
| 01/05/13 | Won | Crescent 44 | Mount Rainier Lutheran 38 | Non-league | 0.986 |
| 01/19/13 | Won | Crescent 48 | Mount Rainier Lutheran 44 | Non-league | 0.986 |
| 01/22/14 | Won | Crescent 46 | Clallam Bay 36 | League | 13.809 |
| 02/04/15 | Won | Crescent 54 | Clallam Bay 52 | League | 18.366 |
| 12/28/16 | Won | Crescent 50 | Quilcene 34 | Non-league | 6.937 |
| 12/08/17 | Won | Crescent 49 | Quilcene 43 | Non-league | 9.580 |
| 12/16/17 | Won | Crescent 49 | Oakville 45 | Non-league | 5.410 |
| 12/19/17 | Won | Crescent 58 | Quilcene 53 | Non-league | 9.580 |
| 12/28/17 | Won | Crescent 43 | Shoreline Christian 42 | Non-league | 13.250 |
| 01/11/18 | Lost | Crescent 41 | Clallam Bay 42 | League | 1.410 |
| 02/02/18 | Lost | Crescent 37 | Clallam Bay 46 | League | 1.410 |
| 12/08/18 | Lost | Crescent 40 | Oakville 48 | Non-league | 8.207 |
| 12/21/18 | Lost | Crescent 38 | Quilcene 42 | Non-league | 0.874 |
| 01/10/19 | Lost | Crescent 42 | Clallam Bay 48 | League | 0.659 |
| 01/10/20 | Won | Crescent 43 | Neah Bay 40 | League | 8.188 |
| 02/05/20 | Won | Crescent 52 | Neah Bay 50 | League | 8.188 |