46 Wins, 33 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01/13/90 | Lost | Grace Academy 26 | Arlington Christian 29 | League | 0.536 |
| 01/27/90 | Lost | Grace Academy 32 | Arlington Christian 35 | League | 0.536 |
| 01/29/90 | Lost | Grace Academy 32 | Sno-King Lutheran 37 | Non-league | 6.670 |
| 12/14/90 | Won | Grace Academy 50 | Snohomish County Christian 38 | League | 0.675 |
| 01/15/91 | Lost | Grace Academy 41 | Lopez 45 | League | 3.250 |
| 01/18/91 | Won | Grace Academy 44 | Snohomish County Christian 32 | League | 0.675 |
| 01/10/92 | Won | Grace Academy 33 | Mount Vernon Christian 25 | League | 3.883 |
| 01/25/92 | Lost | Grace Academy 30 | Snohomish County Christian 38 | Non-league | 10.953 |
| 01/31/92 | Won | Grace Academy 35 | Mount Vernon Christian 34 | League | 3.883 |
| 01/15/93 | Won | Grace Academy 40 | Mount Vernon Christian 31 | League | 16.365 |
| 12/04/93 | Won | Grace Academy 25 | University Prep 21 | Non-league | 9.787 |
| 12/05/95 | Lost | Grace Academy 35 | Seattle Academy 36 | Non-league | 10.226 |
| 01/19/96 | Won | Grace Academy 35 | Lopez 27 | League | 9.884 |
| 02/03/98 | Lost | Grace Academy 39 | Skykomish 44 | League | 4.701 |
| 01/12/99 | Lost | Grace Academy 45 | Lopez 54 | League | 13.451 |
| 02/08/00 | Lost | Grace Academy 37 | Snohomish County Christian 44 | League | 3.398 |
| 02/19/00 | Won | Grace Academy 35 | Kent View Christian 33 | Playoff | 2.744 |
| 12/15/00 | Lost | Grace Academy 49 | Master's Touch Christian 55 | Non-league | 4.517 |
| 12/16/00 | Won | Grace Academy 47 | Cedar Park Christian (Bothell) 21 | Non-league | 0.193 |
| 02/02/01 | Lost | Grace Academy 35 | Snohomish County Christian 54 | League | 4.334 |
| 12/15/01 | Won | Grace Academy 39 | Puget Sound Adventist 27 | Non-league | 3.904 |
| 12/17/02 | Won | Grace Academy 43 | Puget Sound Adventist 38 | Non-league | 0.506 |
| 01/04/03 | Won | Grace Academy 38 | Northwest Yeshiva 28 | Non-league | 1.875 |
| 01/27/03 | Lost | Grace Academy 43 | Bear Creek 49 | Non-league | 2.008 |
| 02/13/03 | Lost | Grace Academy 32 | Snohomish County Christian 43 | League | 2.955 |
| 02/14/03 | Lost | Grace Academy 30 | Snohomish County Christian 34 | Playoff | 2.955 |
| 12/13/03 | Lost | Grace Academy 26 | Northwest Yeshiva 28 | Non-league | 4.031 |
| 12/16/03 | Lost | Grace Academy 31 | Lopez 47 | Non-league | 5.130 |
| 01/09/04 | Lost | Grace Academy 41 | Tulalip Heritage 48 | Non-league | 0.012 |
| 01/04/05 | Won | Grace Academy 40 | Tulalip Heritage 38 | League | 15.775 |
| 01/21/05 | Won | Grace Academy 32 | Master's Touch Christian 31 | League | 9.835 |
| 01/06/06 | Won | Grace Academy 42 | Lopez 27 | League | 4.530 |
| 01/27/06 | Won | Grace Academy 38 | Lopez 32 | League | 4.530 |
| 01/16/07 | Won | Grace Academy 43 | Tulalip Heritage 40 | League | 4.497 |
| 01/23/07 | Won | Grace Academy 44 | Lopez 31 | League | 3.745 |
| 01/12/08 | Won | Grace Academy 49 | Lopez 46 | League | 9.501 |
| 12/12/08 | Won | Grace Academy 36 | Highland Christian 20 | League | 8.889 |
| 12/03/09 | Won | Grace Academy 30 | Mount Vernon Christian 29 | Non-league | 7.221 |
| 12/10/09 | Lost | Grace Academy 41 | Puget Sound Adventist 42 | Non-league | 8.893 |
| 12/28/09 | Lost | Grace Academy 20 | Shoreline Christian 25 | Non-league | 7.073 |
| 01/05/10 | Won | Grace Academy 40 | Lummi Nation 37 | League | 0.323 |
| 01/15/10 | Lost | Grace Academy 47 | Highland Christian 53 | League | 3.188 |
| 01/22/10 | Won | Grace Academy 40 | Lummi Nation 31 | League | 0.323 |
| 02/12/10 | Lost | Grace Academy 28 | Mount Rainier Lutheran 31 | Playoff | 3.910 |
| 02/15/10 | Lost | Grace Academy 49 | Highland Christian 52 | Playoff | 3.188 |
| 12/14/10 | Won | Grace Academy 49 | Lummi Nation 36 | League | 4.417 |
| 01/14/11 | Won | Grace Academy 46 | Tulalip Heritage 39 | League | 12.161 |
| 01/21/11 | Won | Grace Academy 35 | Highland Christian 33 | League | 5.779 |
| 01/25/11 | Won | Grace Academy 33 | Lopez 32 | League | 12.055 |
| 12/09/11 | Won | Grace Academy 37 | Lopez 31 | League | 3.041 |
| 12/14/11 | Won | Grace Academy 40 | Lummi Nation 35 | League | 4.693 |
| 12/16/11 | Won | Grace Academy 47 | Tulalip Heritage 45 | League | 1.775 |
| 01/24/12 | Won | Grace Academy 35 | Lopez 32 | League | 3.041 |
| 01/27/12 | Won | Grace Academy 56 | Lummi Nation 49 | League | 4.693 |
| 02/18/12 | Won | Grace Academy 43 | Mount Rainier Lutheran 32 | Playoff | 1.019 |
| 12/01/12 | Lost | Grace Academy 50 | Northwest Yeshiva 52 | Non-league | 5.577 |
| 12/04/12 | Won | Grace Academy 38 | Lopez 31 | League | 1.397 |
| 01/18/13 | Won | Grace Academy 41 | Lopez 32 | League | 1.397 |
| 02/09/13 | Lost | Grace Academy 47 | Evergreen Lutheran 48 | Playoff | 5.446 |
| 12/11/13 | Won | Grace Academy 42 | Lopez 37 | League | 0.273 |
| 02/05/14 | Won | Grace Academy 53 | Lopez 49 | League | 0.273 |
| 02/08/14 | Won | Grace Academy 58 | Cedar Park Christian (Mountlake Terrace) 46 | Playoff | 1.900 |
| 12/16/14 | Won | Grace Academy 42 | Lopez 34 | League | 10.211 |
| 12/29/14 | Won | Grace Academy 45 | Orcas Christian 40 | League | 5.191 |
| 02/06/16 | Lost | Grace Academy 53 | Lopez 68 | Playoff | 3.624 |
| 02/04/17 | Won | Grace Academy 38 | Lopez 28 | League | 2.777 |
| 02/11/17 | Lost | Grace Academy 23 | Shoreline Christian 28 | Playoff | 2.619 |
| 12/08/17 | Lost | Grace Academy 25 | Shoreline Christian 27 | League | 7.775 |
| 01/09/18 | Won | Grace Academy 49 | Lummi Nation 47 | League | 1.466 |
| 02/01/18 | Won | Grace Academy 48 | Lummi Nation 47 | Playoff | 1.466 |
| 12/01/18 | Lost | Grace Academy 53 | Tacoma Baptist 57 | Non-league | 12.115 |
| 12/29/18 | Won | Grace Academy 42 | Taholah 39 | Non-league | 9.860 |
| 02/23/19 | Lost | Grace Academy 26 | Riverside Christian 29 | Playoff | 6.253 |
| 12/19/19 | Lost | Grace Academy 46 | Tulalip Heritage 49 | League | 2.621 |
| 01/02/20 | Won | Grace Academy 34 | Lummi Nation 31 | League | 3.205 |
| 01/23/20 | Lost | Grace Academy 31 | Tulalip Heritage 38 | League | 2.621 |
| 02/04/20 | Won | Grace Academy 51 | Lummi Nation 35 | League | 3.205 |
| 02/08/20 | Lost | Grace Academy 34 | Tulalip Heritage 40 | Playoff | 2.621 |
| 02/15/20 | Lost | Grace Academy 39 | Puget Sound Adventist 44 | Playoff | 8.544 |
31 Wins, 17 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/05/02 | Won | Grace Academy 56 | Master's Touch Christian 54 | Non-league | 10.750 |
| 12/06/03 | Won | Grace Academy 52 | Master's Touch Christian 46 | Non-league | 3.213 |
| 12/12/03 | Lost | Grace Academy 39 | Skykomish 44 | Non-league | 2.909 |
| 12/16/03 | Won | Grace Academy 49 | Lopez 47 | Non-league | 4.913 |
| 12/16/04 | Won | Grace Academy 48 | Summit 33 | Non-league | 2.332 |
| 01/28/05 | Won | Grace Academy 45 | Tulalip Heritage 41 | League | 4.830 |
| 11/29/05 | Won | Grace Academy 52 | Northwest Yeshiva 39 | Non-league | 1.859 |
| 11/30/06 | Lost | Grace Academy 51 | Northwest Yeshiva 55 | Non-league | 1.234 |
| 12/09/06 | Lost | Grace Academy 45 | Northwest Yeshiva 53 | Non-league | 1.234 |
| 01/05/07 | Won | Grace Academy 44 | Lummi Nation 36 | League | 11.773 |
| 01/12/07 | Lost | Grace Academy 44 | North Sound Christian 49 | League | 7.301 |
| 01/19/07 | Won | Grace Academy 49 | Master's Touch Christian 47 | League | 2.177 |
| 01/23/07 | Won | Grace Academy 53 | Lopez 44 | League | 5.983 |
| 11/27/07 | Won | Grace Academy 59 | Northwest Yeshiva 51 | Non-league | 4.250 |
| 12/06/07 | Won | Grace Academy 64 | Concrete 54 | Non-league | 3.338 |
| 01/08/08 | Won | Grace Academy 52 | Lummi Nation 50 | League | 15.682 |
| 01/02/09 | Won | Grace Academy 33 | Mount Rainier Lutheran 31 | Non-league | 0.223 |
| 01/10/09 | Won | Grace Academy 32 | Highland Christian 27 | League | 11.430 |
| 01/24/09 | Won | Grace Academy 38 | Puget Sound Adventist 29 | Non-league | 3.800 |
| 12/01/09 | Won | Grace Academy 34 | Northwest Yeshiva 23 | Non-league | 6.743 |
| 12/10/09 | Lost | Grace Academy 42 | Puget Sound Adventist 46 | Non-league | 2.028 |
| 01/08/10 | Lost | Grace Academy 45 | Skykomish 50 | Non-league | 4.229 |
| 12/29/10 | Won | Grace Academy 42 | Bush 37 | Non-league | 12.657 |
| 02/08/11 | Lost | Grace Academy 41 | Highland Christian 42 | League | 6.637 |
| 12/27/11 | Won | Grace Academy 41 | Christian Faith 37 | Non-league | 5.066 |
| 01/10/12 | Won | Grace Academy 40 | Lummi Nation 36 | League | 12.857 |
| 01/24/12 | Lost | Grace Academy 34 | Lopez 47 | League | 2.662 |
| 12/01/12 | Won | Grace Academy 52 | Northwest Yeshiva 47 | Non-league | 1.181 |
| 12/11/12 | Won | Grace Academy 48 | Tulalip Heritage 39 | League | 12.652 |
| 12/13/12 | Lost | Grace Academy 44 | Shoreline Christian 45 | Non-league | 10.713 |
| 12/14/12 | Lost | Grace Academy 34 | Mount Vernon Christian 42 | Non-league | 7.437 |
| 02/02/13 | Lost | Grace Academy 50 | Mount Vernon Christian 55 | Playoff | 7.437 |
| 12/17/13 | Lost | Grace Academy 43 | Shoreline Christian 54 | Non-league | 8.900 |
| 02/08/14 | Won | Grace Academy 51 | Mount Vernon Christian 50 | Playoff | 9.892 |
| 02/13/14 | Won | Grace Academy 51 | Cedar Park Christian (Mountlake Terrace) 47 | Playoff | 14.124 |
| 01/03/15 | Lost | Grace Academy 49 | Darrington 55 | Non-league | 23.361 |
| 01/17/15 | Won | Grace Academy 67 | Tulalip Heritage 63 | League | 6.311 |
| 02/10/15 | Lost | Grace Academy 40 | Providence Classical Christian 57 | Playoff | 4.655 |
| 01/05/17 | Won | Grace Academy 33 | Orcas Christian 29 | League | 8.282 |
| 01/12/17 | Lost | Grace Academy 48 | Lopez 50 | League | 4.246 |
| 01/24/17 | Won | Grace Academy 41 | Tulalip Heritage 38 | League | 12.338 |
| 01/09/18 | Won | Grace Academy 42 | Lummi Nation 41 | League | 17.320 |
| 12/01/18 | Won | Grace Academy 44 | Tacoma Baptist 41 | Non-league | 8.488 |
| 01/02/19 | Won | Grace Academy 46 | Lopez 30 | League | 0.294 |
| 11/30/19 | Won | Grace Academy 54 | Tacoma Baptist 30 | Non-league | 11.685 |
| 12/14/19 | Lost | Grace Academy 47 | Northwest Yeshiva 52 | Non-league | 1.202 |
| 01/23/20 | Won | Grace Academy 58 | Tulalip Heritage 43 | League | 5.324 |
| 02/11/20 | Lost | Grace Academy 43 | Lopez 44 | Playoff | 13.824 |