14 Wins, 10 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/10/10 | Won | Muckleshoot 42 | Christian Faith 35 | League | 11.197 |
| 01/27/12 | Won | Muckleshoot 42 | Quilcene 41 | League | 0.341 |
| 12/04/12 | Lost | Muckleshoot 32 | Christian Faith 42 | League | 9.580 |
| 12/06/12 | Lost | Muckleshoot 31 | Shorewood Christian 40 | League | 8.457 |
| 01/12/13 | Lost | Muckleshoot 44 | Christian Faith 45 | League | 9.580 |
| 01/17/14 | Lost | Muckleshoot 37 | Shorewood Christian 42 | League | 11.379 |
| 01/16/15 | Lost | Muckleshoot 34 | Shorewood Christian 41 | League | 10.984 |
| 01/23/15 | Won | Muckleshoot 52 | Quilcene 48 | League | 6.186 |
| 01/27/15 | Won | Muckleshoot 34 | Northwest Yeshiva 29 | League | 3.147 |
| 02/05/15 | Lost | Muckleshoot 37 | Christian Faith 43 | League | 15.775 |
| 02/12/15 | Lost | Muckleshoot 40 | Seattle Lutheran 46 | Playoff | 3.554 |
| 02/19/15 | Won | Muckleshoot 55 | Mount Rainier Lutheran 49 | Playoff | 10.038 |
| 12/10/15 | Won | Muckleshoot 43 | Seattle Lutheran 40 | Non-league | 18.434 |
| 12/18/15 | Lost | Muckleshoot 37 | Crosspoint 44 | League | 5.082 |
| 12/06/16 | Won | Muckleshoot W | Mary M. Knight L | Non-league | 13.920 |
| 12/05/17 | Won | Muckleshoot 60 | Northwest Yeshiva 48 | League | 8.414 |
| 12/27/17 | Won | Muckleshoot 42 | Lummi Nation 38 | Non-league | 2.530 |
| 01/03/18 | Won | Muckleshoot 32 | Quilcene 24 | League | 4.286 |
| 01/06/18 | Won | Muckleshoot 32 | Lummi Nation 29 | Non-league | 2.530 |
| 01/08/18 | Lost | Muckleshoot 37 | Crosspoint 40 | Non-league | 5.103 |
| 02/05/18 | Lost | Muckleshoot 27 | Tacoma Baptist 32 | Playoff | 6.936 |
| 12/08/18 | Won | Muckleshoot 44 | Seattle Lutheran 36 | Non-league | 2.237 |
| 02/07/19 | Won | Muckleshoot 43 | Tacoma Baptist 39 | Playoff | 0.853 |
| 02/18/20 | Won | Muckleshoot 45 | Lummi Nation 41 | Playoff | 3.870 |
15 Wins, 13 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/10/10 | Won | Muckleshoot 72 | Chief Leschi 46 | Non-league | 9.988 |
| 02/25/11 | Lost | Muckleshoot 52 | Taholah 55 | Playoff | 5.057 |
| 12/10/11 | Won | Muckleshoot 74 | Chief Leschi 62 | Non-league | 1.038 |
| 01/10/12 | Lost | Muckleshoot 54 | Puget Sound Adventist 56 | League | 12.658 |
| 02/10/12 | Lost | Muckleshoot 48 | Christian Faith 49 | League | 10.522 |
| 02/17/12 | Lost | Muckleshoot 44 | Lummi Nation 55 | Playoff | 2.731 |
| 02/18/12 | Won | Muckleshoot 57 | Mount Rainier Lutheran 54 | Playoff | 1.613 |
| 03/01/12 | Lost | Muckleshoot 44 | King's Way Christian 61 | Playoff | 8.092 |
| 03/02/12 | Won | Muckleshoot 67 | Moses Lake Christian 57 | Playoff | 5.534 |
| 12/18/12 | Won | Muckleshoot 57 | Puget Sound Adventist 46 | League | 5.873 |
| 01/15/13 | Won | Muckleshoot 71 | Shorewood Christian 56 | League | 3.601 |
| 01/18/13 | Won | Muckleshoot 49 | Evergreen Lutheran 39 | League | 2.544 |
| 02/14/13 | Won | Muckleshoot 45 | Lummi Nation 39 | Playoff | 5.401 |
| 12/19/13 | Won | Muckleshoot 42 | Northwest Yeshiva 35 | League | 19.526 |
| 01/24/14 | Won | Muckleshoot 63 | Rainier Christian 52 | League | 6.440 |
| 02/07/14 | Won | Muckleshoot 47 | Quilcene 32 | League | 5.483 |
| 01/23/15 | Won | Muckleshoot 52 | Quilcene 47 | League | 11.988 |
| 02/03/15 | Won | Muckleshoot 50 | Puget Sound Adventist 49 | League | 12.120 |
| 12/01/17 | Lost | Muckleshoot 74 | Cedar Park Christian (Mountlake Terrace) 79 | Non-league | 13.280 |
| 12/28/17 | Lost | Muckleshoot 79 | Napavine 88 | Non-league | 5.680 |
| 03/01/18 | Lost | Muckleshoot 51 | Almira Coulee Hartline 61 | Playoff | 10.840 |
| 03/02/18 | Lost | Muckleshoot 61 | Odessa 71 | Playoff | 8.460 |
| 12/05/19 | Lost | Muckleshoot 56 | Rainier Christian 59 | League | 6.397 |
| 01/02/20 | Won | Muckleshoot 77 | Walla Walla Valley Academy 59 | Non-league | 0.315 |
| 01/16/20 | Lost | Muckleshoot 53 | Rainier Christian 67 | League | 6.397 |
| 02/01/20 | Lost | Muckleshoot 57 | Evergreen Lutheran 59 | League | 3.560 |
| 02/04/20 | Lost | Muckleshoot 53 | Auburn Adventist 57 | Non-league | 1.552 |
| 03/04/20 | Won | Muckleshoot 64 | Garfield-Palouse 58 | Playoff | 2.781 |