2 Wins, 4 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/29/14 | Lost | Orcas Christian 40 | Grace Academy 45 | League | 5.191 |
| 02/04/15 | Won | Orcas Christian 56 | Lopez 46 | League | 5.019 |
| 01/14/16 | Lost | Orcas Christian L | Lummi Nation W | League | 6.674 |
| 02/01/16 | Lost | Orcas Christian 21 | Lummi Nation 29 | League | 6.674 |
| 01/17/18 | Lost | Orcas Christian 32 | Cedar Park Christian (Mountlake Terrace) 33 | League | 4.970 |
| 01/24/19 | Won | Orcas Christian 31 | Cascade Christian (Wenatchee) 29 | Non-league | 1.515 |
3 Wins, 10 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 02/04/15 | Lost | Orcas Christian 43 | Lopez 46 | League | 13.550 |
| 01/14/16 | Lost | Orcas Christian 71 | Lummi Nation 75 | League | 1.755 |
| 02/15/16 | Lost | Orcas Christian 37 | Tulalip Heritage 43 | Playoff | 11.722 |
| 12/13/16 | Won | Orcas Christian 50 | Tulalip Heritage 39 | League | 4.056 |
| 01/05/17 | Lost | Orcas Christian 29 | Grace Academy 33 | League | 8.282 |
| 01/18/17 | Won | Orcas Christian 53 | Tulalip Heritage 51 | League | 4.056 |
| 01/09/18 | Lost | Orcas Christian 39 | Lopez 43 | League | 1.710 |
| 01/22/18 | Lost | Orcas Christian 42 | Shoreline Christian 62 | League | 2.990 |
| 01/29/18 | Lost | Orcas Christian 48 | Lopez 52 | League | 1.710 |
| 12/11/18 | Lost | Orcas Christian 45 | Lopez 59 | League | 1.786 |
| 01/26/19 | Lost | Orcas Christian 35 | Cascade Christian (Wenatchee) 36 | Non-league | 7.910 |
| 01/31/19 | Won | Orcas Christian 44 | Mount Vernon Christian 41 | Playoff | 0.479 |
| 02/06/19 | Lost | Orcas Christian 47 | Lopez 51 | Playoff | 1.786 |