12 Wins, 11 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01/16/99 | Lost | St. Michael's 50 | Inchelium 55 | League | 6.548 |
| 01/23/99 | Won | St. Michael's 65 | Cusick 45 | League | 15.129 |
| 12/03/99 | Lost | St. Michael's 49 | Moses Lake Christian 51 | Non-league | 4.729 |
| 01/25/03 | Won | St. Michael's 44 | Republic 43 | League | 22.202 |
| 01/28/03 | Won | St. Michael's 42 | Mary Walker 41 | League | 10.379 |
| 01/03/04 | Won | St. Michael's 49 | Mary Walker 40 | League | 8.532 |
| 01/07/05 | Won | St. Michael's 33 | Northport 31 | League | 0.593 |
| 11/30/06 | Won | St. Michael's 48 | Mansfield 41 | Non-league | 0.862 |
| 12/05/06 | Won | St. Michael's 32 | Mansfield 29 | Non-league | 0.862 |
| 12/16/06 | Won | St. Michael's 44 | Northport 41 | League | 10.418 |
| 01/25/08 | Lost | St. Michael's 32 | Columbia (Hunters) 35 | League | 8.486 |
| 12/16/08 | Lost | St. Michael's 51 | Inchelium 54 | League | 0.372 |
| 01/24/09 | Lost | St. Michael's 36 | Wellpinit 49 | League | 7.335 |
| 01/30/09 | Lost | St. Michael's 27 | Curlew 38 | League | 3.153 |
| 02/25/09 | Won | St. Michael's 55 | Taholah 49 | Playoff | 0.506 |
| 01/22/10 | Lost | St. Michael's 34 | Northport 35 | League | 0.497 |
| 01/23/10 | Lost | St. Michael's 21 | Inchelium 39 | League | 6.761 |
| 12/16/11 | Won | St. Michael's 35 | Inchelium 30 | Non-league | 14.343 |
| 11/30/12 | Lost | St. Michael's 39 | Curlew 54 | Non-league | 0.389 |
| 12/01/12 | Lost | St. Michael's 37 | Northport 39 | Non-league | 5.198 |
| 12/18/12 | Won | St. Michael's 48 | Selkirk 41 | Non-league | 10.797 |
| 01/08/13 | Lost | St. Michael's 33 | Valley Christian 34 | League | 5.944 |
| 01/18/13 | Won | St. Michael's 35 | Odessa-Harrington 29 | League | 8.779 |
13 Wins, 13 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01/04/03 | Won | St. Michael's 74 | Mary Walker 58 | League | 2.997 |
| 01/10/03 | Lost | St. Michael's 68 | Wellpinit 76 | League | 6.864 |
| 01/25/03 | Won | St. Michael's 81 | Republic 71 | League | 4.523 |
| 01/16/04 | Lost | St. Michael's 62 | Inchelium 64 | League | 17.825 |
| 02/16/04 | Won | St. Michael's 67 | St. George's 62 | Playoff | 8.108 |
| 01/08/05 | Lost | St. Michael's 70 | Inchelium 75 | League | 9.284 |
| 01/20/06 | Lost | St. Michael's 52 | Northport 66 | League | 7.081 |
| 01/21/06 | Won | St. Michael's 65 | Inchelium 60 | League | 4.558 |
| 01/28/06 | Won | St. Michael's 59 | Cusick 53 | League | 2.661 |
| 12/15/06 | Lost | St. Michael's 53 | Inchelium 65 | League | 1.454 |
| 01/20/07 | Won | St. Michael's 59 | Cusick 55 | League | 4.038 |
| 02/02/07 | Lost | St. Michael's 70 | Inchelium 71 | League | 1.454 |
| 02/07/07 | Lost | St. Michael's 48 | Inchelium 61 | Playoff | 1.454 |
| 12/07/07 | Won | St. Michael's 62 | Northport 53 | League | 5.126 |
| 12/08/07 | Lost | St. Michael's 57 | Inchelium 61 | League | 5.927 |
| 01/18/08 | Won | St. Michael's 50 | Northport 47 | League | 5.126 |
| 01/25/08 | Lost | St. Michael's 57 | Columbia (Hunters) 76 | League | 4.933 |
| 02/09/08 | Won | St. Michael's 65 | Northport 54 | Playoff | 5.126 |
| 12/16/08 | Won | St. Michael's 44 | Inchelium 39 | League | 9.037 |
| 01/20/09 | Won | St. Michael's 69 | Columbia (Hunters) 68 | League | 2.550 |
| 01/31/09 | Won | St. Michael's 68 | Inchelium 49 | League | 9.037 |
| 01/22/10 | Lost | St. Michael's 54 | Northport 56 | League | 0.349 |
| 01/06/11 | Lost | St. Michael's 39 | Inchelium 45 | Non-league | 4.368 |
| 01/21/11 | Won | St. Michael's 67 | Wilbur-Creston 60 | League | 15.779 |
| 11/30/12 | Lost | St. Michael's 47 | Curlew 59 | Non-league | 3.332 |
| 01/22/13 | Lost | St. Michael's 53 | Inchelium 57 | Non-league | 7.619 |