55 Wins, 54 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/30/86 | Won | Toutle Lake 54 | Lake Quinault 50 | Non-league | 11.269 |
| 02/20/87 | Lost | Toutle Lake 37 | North Beach 44 | Playoff | 13.375 |
| 02/11/91 | Won | Toutle Lake 40 | Morton 34 | Playoff | 6.365 |
| 02/15/91 | Won | Toutle Lake 70 | Willapa Valley 64 | Playoff | 7.897 |
| Won | Toutle Lake 61 | Morton 50 | League | 6.365 | |
| 12/09/91 | Lost | Toutle Lake 57 | Willapa Valley 63 | Non-league | 3.876 |
| 02/13/92 | Lost | Toutle Lake 58 | Rainier 59 | League | 8.532 |
| 02/25/92 | Won | Toutle Lake 58 | Raymond 46 | Playoff | 7.441 |
| 01/15/93 | Lost | Toutle Lake 41 | Rainier 47 | League | 6.102 |
| 02/27/93 | Lost | Toutle Lake 44 | Wishkah Valley 48 | Playoff | 1.075 |
| 03/03/93 | Lost | Toutle Lake 52 | Royal 54 | Playoff | 5.218 |
| 03/06/93 | Lost | Toutle Lake 43 | South Bend 47 | Playoff | 1.200 |
| 12/30/94 | Lost | Toutle Lake 52 | Rochester 60 | Non-league | 3.596 |
| 02/18/95 | Lost | Toutle Lake 50 | Lake Quinault 58 | Playoff | 2.750 |
| 12/05/95 | Won | Toutle Lake 53 | La Center 41 | Non-league | 2.634 |
| 12/12/95 | Won | Toutle Lake 62 | La Center 53 | Non-league | 2.634 |
| 01/19/96 | Won | Toutle Lake 52 | Rainier 40 | League | 8.162 |
| 01/20/96 | Lost | Toutle Lake 58 | Napavine 59 | League | 12.908 |
| 01/07/97 | Won | Toutle Lake 58 | Rainier 40 | League | 3.220 |
| 01/22/97 | Lost | Toutle Lake 50 | Mossyrock 58 | League | 5.687 |
| 02/21/97 | Won | Toutle Lake 74 | Wishkah Valley 69 | Playoff | 6.775 |
| 03/06/97 | Won | Toutle Lake 76 | King's West 70 | Playoff | 3.474 |
| 01/09/98 | Won | Toutle Lake 48 | White Pass 45 | League | 5.387 |
| 02/19/98 | Won | Toutle Lake 54 | Onalaska 45 | Playoff | 9.129 |
| 02/26/98 | Won | Toutle Lake 65 | Ilwaco 59 | Playoff | 4.920 |
| 02/28/98 | Won | Toutle Lake 51 | La Center 49 | Playoff | 7.892 |
| 12/04/98 | Lost | Toutle Lake 54 | Mossyrock 59 | Non-league | 5.101 |
| 12/11/98 | Won | Toutle Lake 50 | Rainier 45 | Non-league | 6.537 |
| 02/01/99 | Won | Toutle Lake 48 | White Pass 43 | League | 3.960 |
| 02/04/99 | Won | Toutle Lake 61 | Toledo 60 | League | 2.580 |
| 01/31/00 | Lost | Toutle Lake 53 | White Pass 62 | League | 8.514 |
| 02/07/00 | Lost | Toutle Lake 58 | Toledo 69 | League | 3.660 |
| 02/25/00 | Lost | Toutle Lake 57 | Toledo 67 | Playoff | 3.660 |
| 03/02/00 | Won | Toutle Lake 54 | Colfax 52 | Playoff | 3.407 |
| 03/04/00 | Won | Toutle Lake 55 | Seattle Christian 50 | Playoff | 1.297 |
| 12/08/00 | Lost | Toutle Lake 72 | Pe Ell 73 | Non-league | 18.444 |
| 12/16/00 | Won | Toutle Lake 50 | Eatonville 49 | Non-league | 7.846 |
| 02/24/01 | Lost | Toutle Lake 64 | Toledo 66 | Playoff | 2.821 |
| 03/02/01 | Lost | Toutle Lake 58 | Cascade Christian (Puyallup) 63 | Playoff | 13.219 |
| 12/14/01 | Won | Toutle Lake 55 | Castle Rock 51 | Non-league | 7.249 |
| 01/04/02 | Won | Toutle Lake 50 | Winlock 35 | League | 0.856 |
| 01/14/02 | Lost | Toutle Lake 50 | Pe Ell 57 | Non-league | 4.594 |
| 01/24/02 | Lost | Toutle Lake 45 | Napavine 52 | League | 0.496 |
| 02/16/02 | Lost | Toutle Lake 41 | Rainier 52 | Playoff | 1.175 |
| 12/10/02 | Won | Toutle Lake 49 | Napavine 44 | League | 4.597 |
| 01/03/03 | Won | Toutle Lake 53 | Castle Rock 37 | Non-league | 4.263 |
| 01/07/03 | Won | Toutle Lake 40 | Winlock 33 | League | 6.867 |
| 01/14/03 | Lost | Toutle Lake 61 | Adna 65 | League | 0.294 |
| 01/17/03 | Won | Toutle Lake 52 | Raymond 43 | League | 0.049 |
| 02/03/03 | Won | Toutle Lake 56 | Toledo 48 | League | 2.327 |
| 02/06/03 | Lost | Toutle Lake 55 | White Pass 58 | League | 13.699 |
| 02/10/03 | Lost | Toutle Lake 42 | Kalama 57 | League | 3.429 |
| 02/15/03 | Lost | Toutle Lake L | Kalama W | Playoff | 3.429 |
| 12/16/03 | Lost | Toutle Lake 55 | White Pass 66 | League | 1.525 |
| 01/19/04 | Lost | Toutle Lake L | Rainier W | League | 17.754 |
| 01/08/05 | Lost | Toutle Lake 46 | Toledo 51 | Non-league | 3.845 |
| 02/03/05 | Won | Toutle Lake 52 | Mossyrock 49 | League | 11.873 |
| 02/26/05 | Won | Toutle Lake 60 | Mossyrock 53 | Playoff | 11.873 |
| 11/30/05 | Lost | Toutle Lake 47 | Toledo 48 | Non-league | 11.734 |
| 03/01/06 | Lost | Toutle Lake 43 | Evergreen Lutheran 55 | Playoff | 12.716 |
| 12/06/06 | Won | Toutle Lake 62 | White Pass 43 | League | 3.413 |
| 02/28/07 | Lost | Toutle Lake 48 | Evergreen Lutheran 50 | Playoff | 2.025 |
| 12/03/07 | Won | Toutle Lake 44 | Toledo 39 | Non-league | 2.654 |
| 12/28/07 | Won | Toutle Lake 51 | Mossyrock 46 | Non-league | 4.749 |
| 01/10/08 | Won | Toutle Lake 55 | White Pass 47 | League | 9.913 |
| 02/15/08 | Lost | Toutle Lake 36 | Raymond 43 | Playoff | 5.918 |
| 02/22/08 | Lost | Toutle Lake 40 | Tacoma Baptist 45 | Playoff | 7.605 |
| 01/17/09 | Won | Toutle Lake 42 | Wahkiakum 37 | League | 3.130 |
| 01/27/09 | Won | Toutle Lake 56 | Wahkiakum 52 | League | 3.130 |
| 02/03/09 | Lost | Toutle Lake 39 | Adna 49 | League | 6.914 |
| 02/19/09 | Won | Toutle Lake 46 | Raymond 25 | Playoff | 1.392 |
| 02/25/09 | Lost | Toutle Lake 40 | North Beach 43 | Playoff | 6.242 |
| 03/04/09 | Won | Toutle Lake 48 | Entiat 46 | Playoff | 10.421 |
| 01/21/10 | Lost | Toutle Lake 39 | White Pass 46 | League | 17.204 |
| 02/02/10 | Lost | Toutle Lake 53 | Adna 55 | League | 9.618 |
| 02/24/10 | Lost | Toutle Lake 28 | Northwest Christian (Lacey) 39 | Playoff | 5.574 |
| 03/04/10 | Won | Toutle Lake 51 | Liberty Bell 49 | Playoff | 1.800 |
| 03/06/10 | Won | Toutle Lake 45 | Napavine 39 | Playoff | 8.512 |
| 12/16/10 | Won | Toutle Lake 44 | Napavine 40 | League | 0.460 |
| 02/17/11 | Lost | Toutle Lake 51 | Adna 54 | Playoff | 12.359 |
| 03/03/11 | Won | Toutle Lake 41 | Brewster 32 | Playoff | 6.351 |
| 12/01/11 | Lost | Toutle Lake 33 | Kalama 36 | Non-league | 18.002 |
| 01/25/12 | Lost | Toutle Lake 56 | Morton-White Pass 60 | League | 7.410 |
| 02/18/12 | Won | Toutle Lake 46 | North Beach 31 | Playoff | 1.575 |
| 02/25/12 | Lost | Toutle Lake 45 | Bear Creek 47 | Playoff | 3.445 |
| 12/12/12 | Won | Toutle Lake 59 | Napavine 48 | League | 7.804 |
| 12/19/12 | Lost | Toutle Lake 41 | Morton-White Pass 46 | League | 1.330 |
| 01/17/13 | Won | Toutle Lake 44 | Napavine 42 | League | 7.804 |
| 01/22/13 | Lost | Toutle Lake 43 | Morton-White Pass 50 | League | 1.330 |
| 01/31/13 | Lost | Toutle Lake 50 | Wahkiakum 52 | League | 12.593 |
| 03/08/14 | Lost | Toutle Lake 38 | Colfax 45 | Playoff | 6.156 |
| 12/20/14 | Won | Toutle Lake 52 | Napavine 35 | League | 0.777 |
| 01/14/15 | Won | Toutle Lake 49 | Wahkiakum 45 | League | 2.135 |
| 02/05/15 | Won | Toutle Lake 46 | Wahkiakum 36 | League | 2.135 |
| 03/06/15 | Won | Toutle Lake 48 | Mabton 45 | Playoff | 2.884 |
| 03/07/15 | Won | Toutle Lake 46 | Colfax 41 | Playoff | 7.708 |
| 01/14/16 | Lost | Toutle Lake 48 | Napavine 64 | League | 0.791 |
| 02/04/16 | Lost | Toutle Lake 51 | Wahkiakum 52 | League | 12.686 |
| 03/03/16 | Lost | Toutle Lake 45 | Mabton 54 | Playoff | 4.801 |
| 02/08/17 | Lost | Toutle Lake 40 | North Beach 42 | Playoff | 9.116 |
| 01/16/18 | Lost | Toutle Lake 29 | Pe Ell 30 | League | 2.729 |
| 12/12/18 | Won | Toutle Lake 39 | Winlock 36 | Non-league | 4.100 |
| 01/15/19 | Won | Toutle Lake 39 | Morton-White Pass 36 | League | 1.101 |
| 01/28/19 | Won | Toutle Lake 39 | Winlock 37 | League | 4.100 |
| 12/07/19 | Lost | Toutle Lake 34 | Castle Rock 52 | Non-league | 8.686 |
| 12/28/19 | Lost | Toutle Lake 34 | Naselle 49 | Non-league | 3.337 |
| 01/02/20 | Won | Toutle Lake 42 | Adna 39 | League | 28.154 |
| 01/21/20 | Lost | Toutle Lake 45 | Morton-White Pass 49 | League | 17.115 |
| 01/28/20 | Won | Toutle Lake 49 | Onalaska 29 | League | 10.651 |
32 Wins, 45 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 02/14/03 | Lost | Toutle Lake 32 | Winlock 41 | League | 9.917 |
| 02/21/03 | Lost | Toutle Lake 22 | Winlock 24 | Playoff | 9.917 |
| 02/28/03 | Lost | Toutle Lake 32 | North Beach 34 | Playoff | 12.286 |
| 12/15/03 | Won | Toutle Lake 52 | White Pass 48 | League | 2.682 |
| 01/10/04 | Lost | Toutle Lake 63 | Winlock 67 | League | 2.060 |
| 01/23/04 | Lost | Toutle Lake 54 | Ocosta 66 | League | 19.930 |
| 01/27/04 | Lost | Toutle Lake 47 | North Beach 48 | League | 2.944 |
| 02/06/04 | Won | Toutle Lake 64 | White Pass 62 | League | 2.682 |
| 12/10/04 | Won | Toutle Lake 56 | Castle Rock 53 | Non-league | 7.541 |
| 01/11/05 | Lost | Toutle Lake 42 | Mossyrock 45 | League | 5.033 |
| 02/02/05 | Won | Toutle Lake 61 | Wahkiakum 50 | League | 1.736 |
| 02/04/05 | Lost | Toutle Lake 45 | Mossyrock 47 | League | 5.033 |
| 02/15/05 | Won | Toutle Lake 50 | North Beach 48 | Playoff | 11.761 |
| 02/21/05 | Won | Toutle Lake 57 | Wahkiakum 40 | Playoff | 1.736 |
| 12/20/05 | Lost | Toutle Lake 49 | Adna 59 | League | 13.144 |
| 02/25/06 | Won | Toutle Lake 71 | Willapa Valley 63 | Playoff | 1.297 |
| 01/12/07 | Lost | Toutle Lake 52 | White Pass 57 | League | 12.446 |
| 01/27/07 | Won | Toutle Lake 54 | Toledo 45 | Non-league | 3.882 |
| 01/31/07 | Lost | Toutle Lake 59 | Mossyrock 60 | League | 9.026 |
| 02/24/07 | Won | Toutle Lake 51 | Wahkiakum 42 | Playoff | 5.829 |
| 03/01/07 | Lost | Toutle Lake 27 | Darrington 35 | Playoff | 9.015 |
| 03/03/07 | Lost | Toutle Lake 41 | Riverside Christian 43 | Playoff | 2.575 |
| 03/01/08 | Lost | Toutle Lake 41 | Northwest Christian (Colbert) 42 | Playoff | 1.692 |
| 01/06/09 | Won | Toutle Lake 52 | Pe Ell 36 | League | 2.813 |
| 01/10/09 | Won | Toutle Lake 47 | Napavine 45 | League | 8.811 |
| 01/31/09 | Lost | Toutle Lake 42 | White Pass 44 | League | 2.394 |
| 02/04/09 | Won | Toutle Lake 59 | Adna 42 | League | 3.249 |
| 02/10/09 | Lost | Toutle Lake 43 | White Pass 51 | League | 2.394 |
| 02/18/09 | Won | Toutle Lake 38 | Adna 34 | Playoff | 3.249 |
| 12/21/09 | Won | Toutle Lake 52 | Napavine 39 | League | 2.388 |
| 12/29/09 | Lost | Toutle Lake 53 | Toledo 67 | Non-league | 2.451 |
| 01/14/10 | Lost | Toutle Lake 55 | Mossyrock 57 | League | 7.165 |
| 01/16/10 | Lost | Toutle Lake 50 | Castle Rock 53 | Non-league | 0.218 |
| 02/05/10 | Won | Toutle Lake 64 | Pe Ell 60 | League | 10.327 |
| 02/17/10 | Won | Toutle Lake 45 | Adna 35 | Playoff | 4.501 |
| 02/27/10 | Won | Toutle Lake 41 | Napavine 29 | Playoff | 2.388 |
| 03/03/10 | Lost | Toutle Lake 35 | La Conner 51 | Playoff | 0.837 |
| 12/10/10 | Won | Toutle Lake 49 | Kalama 47 | Non-league | 3.145 |
| 12/15/10 | Lost | Toutle Lake 53 | Mossyrock 73 | League | 0.935 |
| 12/22/10 | Won | Toutle Lake 64 | Morton-White Pass 54 | League | 0.128 |
| 12/29/10 | Won | Toutle Lake 50 | Toledo 46 | Non-league | 4.484 |
| 01/14/11 | Lost | Toutle Lake 56 | Wahkiakum 57 | League | 3.933 |
| 01/25/11 | Won | Toutle Lake 53 | Morton-White Pass 52 | League | 0.128 |
| 01/27/11 | Won | Toutle Lake 60 | Pe Ell 59 | League | 2.082 |
| 02/01/11 | Won | Toutle Lake 51 | Adna 43 | League | 14.087 |
| 12/21/11 | Lost | Toutle Lake 55 | Morton-White Pass 60 | League | 9.387 |
| 12/30/11 | Lost | Toutle Lake 59 | La Conner 67 | Non-league | 0.304 |
| 01/06/12 | Won | Toutle Lake 65 | Adna 62 | League | 6.551 |
| 03/02/12 | Lost | Toutle Lake 44 | Colfax 58 | Playoff | 1.496 |
| 03/03/12 | Won | Toutle Lake 48 | Adna 45 | Playoff | 6.551 |
| 12/20/12 | Won | Toutle Lake 56 | Winlock 48 | League | 9.307 |
| 01/11/14 | Won | Toutle Lake 61 | Wahkiakum 47 | League | 7.801 |
| 02/05/14 | Lost | Toutle Lake 55 | Adna 62 | League | 0.341 |
| 02/17/14 | Lost | Toutle Lake 43 | Napavine 52 | Playoff | 1.721 |
| 12/13/14 | Won | Toutle Lake 66 | Pe Ell 53 | League | 2.495 |
| 01/30/15 | Won | Toutle Lake 44 | Onalaska 39 | League | 10.563 |
| 12/08/15 | Lost | Toutle Lake 49 | Mossyrock 54 | League | 1.009 |
| 12/10/15 | Lost | Toutle Lake 43 | Toledo 50 | League | 0.600 |
| 12/22/15 | Won | Toutle Lake 62 | Napavine 49 | League | 2.232 |
| 01/20/16 | Lost | Toutle Lake 60 | Mossyrock 70 | League | 1.009 |
| 01/22/16 | Lost | Toutle Lake 45 | Toledo 66 | League | 0.600 |
| 02/08/16 | Lost | Toutle Lake 55 | Chief Leschi 63 | Playoff | 11.232 |
| 12/06/16 | Lost | Toutle Lake 55 | Kalama 56 | League | 3.836 |
| 12/30/16 | Lost | Toutle Lake 28 | Burlington-Edison 41 | Non-league | 2.881 |
| 02/01/17 | Lost | Toutle Lake 55 | Toledo 60 | League | 1.924 |
| 02/15/17 | Lost | Toutle Lake 61 | Chief Leschi 64 | Playoff | 5.516 |
| 12/14/17 | Lost | Toutle Lake 45 | Toledo 54 | League | 3.830 |
| 01/10/18 | Lost | Toutle Lake 67 | Napavine 70 | League | 3.920 |
| 01/31/18 | Lost | Toutle Lake 56 | Toledo 58 | League | 3.830 |
| 03/03/18 | Lost | Toutle Lake 41 | Brewster 57 | Playoff | 3.690 |
| 12/04/18 | Lost | Toutle Lake 51 | Adna 64 | Non-league | 1.725 |
| 12/11/18 | Won | Toutle Lake 50 | Toledo 46 | Non-league | 7.120 |
| 12/28/18 | Lost | Toutle Lake 34 | Cedar Park Christian (Bothell) 57 | Non-league | 6.292 |
| 02/13/19 | Lost | Toutle Lake 44 | Willapa Valley 46 | Playoff | 3.851 |
| 12/27/19 | Lost | Toutle Lake 59 | Yakama Tribal 70 | Non-league | 3.505 |
| 01/22/20 | Lost | Toutle Lake 64 | Morton-White Pass 67 | League | 12.700 |
| 02/29/20 | Won | Toutle Lake 59 | Lake Roosevelt 43 | Playoff | 2.579 |