65 Wins, 49 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/02/86 | Lost | Vashon Island 41 | Mount Tahoma 42 | Non-league | 2.448 |
| 12/19/86 | Won | Vashon Island 44 | Port Townsend 32 | League | 3.881 |
| 01/30/87 | Lost | Vashon Island 29 | Tacoma Baptist 40 | League | 3.080 |
| 02/06/87 | Won | Vashon Island 58 | North Mason 46 | League | 3.127 |
| 01/05/88 | Lost | Vashon Island 32 | Charles Wright 33 | League | 12.324 |
| 01/26/88 | Lost | Vashon Island 37 | Orting 39 | League | 8.004 |
| 12/09/88 | Won | Vashon Island 37 | Mount Tahoma 32 | Non-league | 14.026 |
| 12/16/88 | Won | Vashon Island 44 | Steilacoom 38 | League | 0.998 |
| 01/10/89 | Won | Vashon Island 45 | Port Townsend 44 | League | 2.841 |
| 02/10/89 | Won | Vashon Island 34 | Seattle Christian 20 | League | 2.514 |
| 02/14/89 | Lost | Vashon Island 51 | Orting 57 | League | 2.362 |
| 12/05/89 | Lost | Vashon Island 37 | King's 44 | Non-league | 2.202 |
| 01/05/90 | Lost | Vashon Island 44 | Chimacum 52 | League | 5.608 |
| 01/30/90 | Won | Vashon Island 49 | Steilacoom 48 | League | 12.606 |
| 01/29/91 | Lost | Vashon Island 45 | Eatonville 50 | League | 6.748 |
| 02/23/91 | Won | Vashon Island 33 | Port Townsend 29 | Playoff | 0.959 |
| 12/11/91 | Lost | Vashon Island 31 | Bush 37 | Non-league | 7.015 |
| 01/07/92 | Lost | Vashon Island 41 | North Mason 53 | League | 0.129 |
| 01/28/92 | Won | Vashon Island 40 | Eatonville 39 | League | 8.742 |
| 02/11/92 | Won | Vashon Island 51 | Eatonville 33 | League | 8.742 |
| 02/18/92 | Lost | Vashon Island 45 | Port Townsend 52 | League | 3.049 |
| 01/04/94 | Won | Vashon Island 43 | Port Townsend 26 | League | 0.266 |
| 01/18/94 | Lost | Vashon Island 44 | Charles Wright 50 | League | 3.370 |
| 01/25/94 | Won | Vashon Island 53 | Eatonville 41 | League | 1.525 |
| 02/11/94 | Lost | Vashon Island 44 | Steilacoom 47 | League | 2.861 |
| 12/06/94 | Won | Vashon Island 56 | Charles Wright 40 | League | 4.657 |
| 01/06/95 | Won | Vashon Island 37 | Seattle Christian 36 | League | 4.407 |
| 01/10/95 | Lost | Vashon Island 37 | Steilacoom 38 | League | 0.906 |
| 02/10/95 | Lost | Vashon Island 43 | Steilacoom 51 | League | 0.906 |
| 02/18/95 | Lost | Vashon Island 33 | Steilacoom 42 | Playoff | 0.906 |
| 12/19/95 | Won | Vashon Island 44 | Seattle Christian 38 | League | 6.136 |
| 01/09/96 | Lost | Vashon Island 52 | Steilacoom 54 | League | 16.981 |
| 12/07/96 | Lost | Vashon Island 51 | Clover Park 53 | Non-league | 7.518 |
| 01/17/97 | Lost | Vashon Island 39 | Charles Wright 41 | League | 1.155 |
| 01/31/97 | Lost | Vashon Island 42 | Seattle Christian 48 | League | 3.561 |
| 02/11/97 | Lost | Vashon Island 60 | Charles Wright 71 | League | 1.155 |
| 03/01/97 | Lost | Vashon Island 56 | Seattle Christian 57 | Playoff | 3.561 |
| 12/05/97 | Won | Vashon Island 60 | Sultan 53 | Non-league | 0.955 |
| 01/02/98 | Won | Vashon Island 55 | Nooksack Valley 50 | Non-league | 1.774 |
| 01/03/98 | Lost | Vashon Island 48 | Mount Baker 60 | Non-league | 2.277 |
| 02/10/98 | Won | Vashon Island 51 | Eatonville 47 | League | 3.759 |
| 02/13/98 | Won | Vashon Island 42 | Charles Wright 38 | Non-league | 1.420 |
| 03/07/98 | Won | Vashon Island 49 | Port Townsend 45 | Playoff | 7.744 |
| 12/12/98 | Won | Vashon Island 45 | Highline 32 | Non-league | 10.022 |
| 01/09/99 | Lost | Vashon Island 36 | Klahowya 44 | Non-league | 5.362 |
| 12/07/99 | Won | Vashon Island 40 | Life Christian 34 | Non-league | 3.553 |
| 12/10/99 | Lost | Vashon Island 36 | Highline 39 | Non-league | 0.776 |
| 01/14/00 | Lost | Vashon Island 47 | Steilacoom 49 | League | 3.819 |
| 12/11/00 | Lost | Vashon Island 57 | North Mason 61 | Non-league | 6.710 |
| 01/12/01 | Won | Vashon Island 47 | Orting 46 | League | 8.812 |
| 01/19/01 | Lost | Vashon Island 38 | Chimacum 40 | League | 8.267 |
| 02/09/01 | Lost | Vashon Island 40 | Foster 41 | League | 8.461 |
| 12/07/01 | Lost | Vashon Island 42 | Lakes 61 | Non-league | 1.588 |
| 12/12/01 | Lost | Vashon Island 47 | North Mason 51 | Non-league | 17.509 |
| 02/12/02 | Won | Vashon Island 58 | Port Townsend 51 | League | 0.812 |
| 12/09/02 | Won | Vashon Island 46 | Seattle Christian 33 | Non-league | 2.155 |
| 12/10/02 | Won | Vashon Island 42 | Cedarcrest 33 | Non-league | 9.055 |
| 02/07/03 | Lost | Vashon Island 35 | Orting 36 | League | 1.302 |
| 02/28/03 | Lost | Vashon Island 39 | Orting 42 | Playoff | 1.302 |
| 12/02/03 | Won | Vashon Island 48 | Life Christian 47 | Non-league | 11.800 |
| 12/04/03 | Lost | Vashon Island 39 | Charles Wright 45 | Non-league | 0.196 |
| 12/09/03 | Won | Vashon Island 43 | Seattle Christian 41 | Non-league | 11.948 |
| 12/19/03 | Won | Vashon Island 50 | Forks 45 | Non-league | 8.959 |
| 01/21/04 | Lost | Vashon Island 42 | Forest Ridge 46 | Non-league | 1.631 |
| 02/27/04 | Won | Vashon Island 50 | Chimacum 46 | Playoff | 1.496 |
| 12/29/04 | Won | Vashon Island 65 | Sedro-Woolley 61 | Non-league | 1.411 |
| 01/14/05 | Won | Vashon Island 57 | North Mason 49 | League | 10.224 |
| 01/18/05 | Won | Vashon Island 45 | Chimacum 38 | League | 1.761 |
| 01/25/05 | Won | Vashon Island 58 | Sequim 48 | League | 9.778 |
| 02/23/05 | Won | Vashon Island 44 | Orting 41 | Playoff | 6.623 |
| 01/03/06 | Won | Vashon Island 46 | Port Townsend 39 | League | 4.394 |
| 01/17/06 | Lost | Vashon Island 56 | Chimacum 63 | League | 3.079 |
| 01/24/06 | Won | Vashon Island 67 | Sequim 65 | League | 1.563 |
| 01/27/06 | Won | Vashon Island 56 | Foster 52 | League | 5.343 |
| 02/25/06 | Won | Vashon Island 54 | Foster 52 | Playoff | 5.343 |
| 03/04/06 | Won | Vashon Island 46 | Port Townsend 44 | Playoff | 4.394 |
| 12/20/06 | Won | Vashon Island 55 | Foster 53 | Non-league | 11.045 |
| 02/17/07 | Won | Vashon Island 52 | Seattle Christian 51 | Playoff | 10.938 |
| 12/01/07 | Lost | Vashon Island 39 | Sultan 53 | Non-league | 2.567 |
| 12/11/07 | Won | Vashon Island 43 | Seattle Christian 39 | League | 9.557 |
| 02/23/08 | Won | Vashon Island 56 | Seattle Christian 52 | Playoff | 9.557 |
| 02/28/08 | Won | Vashon Island 46 | Bellevue Christian 44 | Playoff | 1.127 |
| 12/12/08 | Won | Vashon Island 59 | Eatonville 57 | Non-league | 5.753 |
| 01/31/09 | Lost | Vashon Island 37 | Auburn Adventist 39 | Non-league | 13.551 |
| 02/28/09 | Won | Vashon Island 45 | Nooksack Valley 42 | Playoff | 5.968 |
| 12/11/09 | Won | Vashon Island 54 | Eatonville 47 | Non-league | 11.255 |
| 01/26/10 | Lost | Vashon Island 36 | Cascade Christian (Puyallup) 45 | League | 10.950 |
| 03/04/10 | Won | Vashon Island 41 | Toledo 34 | Playoff | 3.971 |
| 12/04/10 | Won | Vashon Island 39 | Port Townsend 38 | Non-league | 5.188 |
| 12/20/10 | Won | Vashon Island 35 | Northwest Christian (Lacey) 30 | Non-league | 0.768 |
| 12/02/11 | Won | Vashon Island 41 | Washington 40 | Non-league | 11.936 |
| 12/22/11 | Won | Vashon Island 52 | Fife 48 | Non-league | 9.160 |
| 01/24/12 | Lost | Vashon Island 33 | Life Christian 36 | League | 5.808 |
| 02/03/12 | Lost | Vashon Island 28 | Charles Wright 38 | League | 0.529 |
| 12/04/12 | Won | Vashon Island 32 | Cedar Park Christian (Bothell) 31 | League | 11.766 |
| 01/22/13 | Won | Vashon Island 36 | Life Christian 24 | League | 5.062 |
| 01/10/14 | Lost | Vashon Island 29 | Chimacum 36 | League | 17.274 |
| 01/24/14 | Won | Vashon Island 33 | Seattle Christian 32 | League | 8.514 |
| 02/01/14 | Won | Vashon Island 37 | Life Christian 26 | League | 0.683 |
| 12/01/14 | Lost | Vashon Island 42 | Peninsula 56 | Non-league | 0.062 |
| 01/23/15 | Won | Vashon Island 41 | Charles Wright 40 | League | 4.437 |
| 01/20/16 | Won | Vashon Island 42 | Cascade Christian (Puyallup) 41 | League | 1.770 |
| 01/22/16 | Won | Vashon Island 48 | Charles Wright 34 | League | 12.383 |
| 02/05/16 | Won | Vashon Island 50 | Cascade Christian (Puyallup) 40 | League | 1.770 |
| 11/29/16 | Lost | Vashon Island 41 | Northwest 46 | Non-league | 7.336 |
| 12/17/16 | Lost | Vashon Island 32 | Aberdeen 33 | Non-league | 1.157 |
| 12/20/16 | Lost | Vashon Island 35 | Sultan 41 | Non-league | 0.706 |
| 12/28/16 | Won | Vashon Island 40 | Chimacum 36 | Non-league | 1.246 |
| 12/07/17 | Won | Vashon Island 34 | Tenino 33 | Non-league | 3.891 |
| 12/12/17 | Lost | Vashon Island 38 | Granite Falls 44 | Non-league | 2.153 |
| 01/15/19 | Won | Vashon Island 42 | Cascade Christian (Puyallup) 38 | League | 14.876 |
| 01/21/19 | Lost | Vashon Island 33 | Chimacum 42 | Non-league | 1.569 |
| 12/10/19 | Won | Vashon Island 41 | Northwest 36 | Non-league | 4.435 |
| 01/02/20 | Lost | Vashon Island 22 | Chimacum 29 | Non-league | 0.657 |
29 Wins, 33 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/17/02 | Won | Vashon Island 61 | Klahowya 56 | Non-league | 0.201 |
| 01/10/03 | Won | Vashon Island 54 | Chimacum 50 | League | 9.576 |
| 01/31/03 | Won | Vashon Island 55 | Foster 53 | League | 4.430 |
| 02/11/03 | Lost | Vashon Island 55 | Port Townsend 82 | League | 1.603 |
| 12/04/03 | Won | Vashon Island 63 | King's West 53 | Non-league | 1.650 |
| 01/20/04 | Lost | Vashon Island 52 | Chimacum 54 | League | 9.367 |
| 01/23/04 | Lost | Vashon Island 53 | Klahowya 67 | League | 3.178 |
| 03/05/04 | Lost | Vashon Island 61 | Klahowya 64 | Playoff | 3.178 |
| 12/01/04 | Lost | Vashon Island 46 | Peninsula 51 | Non-league | 6.611 |
| 01/18/05 | Lost | Vashon Island 65 | Chimacum 67 | League | 11.852 |
| 01/25/05 | Lost | Vashon Island 52 | Sequim 56 | League | 3.252 |
| 02/10/05 | Won | Vashon Island 39 | Seattle Christian 33 | League | 3.068 |
| 03/04/05 | Lost | Vashon Island 49 | Steilacoom 54 | Playoff | 5.058 |
| 01/17/06 | Lost | Vashon Island 56 | Chimacum 62 | League | 16.654 |
| 03/11/06 | Won | Vashon Island 67 | Grandview 59 | Playoff | 0.548 |
| 12/30/06 | Won | Vashon Island 61 | Newport (Bellevue) 57 | Non-league | 1.047 |
| 02/22/07 | Lost | Vashon Island 49 | King's 54 | Playoff | 0.411 |
| 02/24/07 | Lost | Vashon Island 59 | Meridian 60 | Playoff | 9.225 |
| 01/04/08 | Lost | Vashon Island 56 | Cascade Christian (Puyallup) 58 | League | 2.826 |
| 02/08/08 | Lost | Vashon Island 38 | Charles Wright 47 | League | 4.285 |
| 02/16/08 | Lost | Vashon Island 44 | Seattle Christian 47 | Playoff | 5.252 |
| 02/22/08 | Won | Vashon Island 58 | King's 56 | Playoff | 8.493 |
| 02/23/08 | Lost | Vashon Island 38 | Charles Wright 47 | Playoff | 4.285 |
| 02/28/08 | Lost | Vashon Island 42 | White Swan 46 | Playoff | 3.087 |
| 02/29/08 | Lost | Vashon Island 36 | Brewster 48 | Playoff | 2.242 |
| 12/18/09 | Won | Vashon Island 59 | Cascade Christian (Puyallup) 50 | League | 2.682 |
| 03/03/10 | Won | Vashon Island 66 | Chelan 52 | Playoff | 5.584 |
| 12/10/10 | Lost | Vashon Island 40 | Seattle Christian 49 | League | 4.118 |
| 12/17/10 | Won | Vashon Island 61 | Life Christian 59 | League | 8.008 |
| 12/30/10 | Lost | Vashon Island 41 | Connell 48 | Non-league | 13.785 |
| 01/25/11 | Won | Vashon Island 67 | Life Christian 62 | League | 8.008 |
| 02/26/11 | Won | Vashon Island 50 | Hoquiam 43 | Playoff | 3.910 |
| 01/10/12 | Won | Vashon Island 49 | Charles Wright 40 | League | 5.701 |
| 01/13/12 | Won | Vashon Island 55 | Chimacum 52 | League | 4.543 |
| 02/07/12 | Won | Vashon Island 60 | Chimacum 55 | League | 4.543 |
| 12/14/12 | Won | Vashon Island 57 | Cascade Christian (Puyallup) 44 | League | 2.518 |
| 12/11/13 | Won | Vashon Island 65 | Cedar Park Christian (Bothell) 42 | League | 3.373 |
| 01/14/14 | Lost | Vashon Island 65 | Eatonville 66 | League | 22.283 |
| 02/21/14 | Lost | Vashon Island 43 | Cascade Christian (Puyallup) 45 | Playoff | 8.512 |
| 12/06/14 | Won | Vashon Island 51 | Kennedy Catholic 50 | Non-league | 9.408 |
| 12/13/14 | Won | Vashon Island 54 | Hazen 44 | Non-league | 1.094 |
| 12/15/15 | Lost | Vashon Island 47 | Seattle Academy 55 | Non-league | 0.794 |
| 02/05/16 | Lost | Vashon Island 41 | Cascade Christian (Puyallup) 47 | League | 3.112 |
| 02/16/16 | Lost | Vashon Island 61 | Seattle Christian 64 | Playoff | 11.965 |
| 12/20/16 | Lost | Vashon Island 39 | Sultan 48 | Non-league | 13.497 |
| 01/18/17 | Won | Vashon Island 52 | Cascade Christian (Puyallup) 48 | League | 4.608 |
| 01/27/17 | Won | Vashon Island 52 | Seattle Christian 45 | League | 1.814 |
| 02/03/17 | Won | Vashon Island 48 | Cascade Christian (Puyallup) 42 | League | 4.608 |
| 02/15/17 | Won | Vashon Island 41 | Seattle Christian 35 | Playoff | 1.814 |
| 02/25/17 | Lost | Vashon Island 40 | King's Way Christian 53 | Playoff | 0.474 |
| 12/09/17 | Lost | Vashon Island 46 | Archbishop Murphy 54 | Non-league | 3.330 |
| 01/15/18 | Won | Vashon Island 46 | Kentlake 39 | Non-league | 4.000 |
| 01/23/18 | Lost | Vashon Island 44 | Charles Wright 48 | League | 14.150 |
| 01/26/18 | Lost | Vashon Island 52 | Seattle Christian 54 | League | 2.400 |
| 02/02/18 | Won | Vashon Island 56 | Cascade Christian (Puyallup) 54 | League | 0.970 |
| 02/06/18 | Won | Vashon Island 53 | Bellevue Christian 46 | League | 2.360 |
| 12/28/18 | Lost | Vashon Island 69 | Forks 70 | Non-league | 10.957 |
| 01/04/19 | Won | Vashon Island 49 | Bellevue Christian 39 | League | 0.401 |
| 02/14/19 | Lost | Vashon Island 29 | Cascade Christian (Puyallup) 41 | Playoff | 6.956 |
| 02/16/19 | Lost | Vashon Island 47 | Cascade Christian (Puyallup) 50 | Playoff | 6.956 |
| 12/14/19 | Won | Vashon Island 41 | Kent-Meridian 33 | Non-league | 3.189 |
| 01/07/20 | Lost | Vashon Island 32 | Klahowya 33 | Non-league | 15.609 |